Post by nephillymike on May 15, 2023 20:55:14 GMT -5
Considering previous discussions on the draft compilation of six sources, the presence of starters and All-Pros by round drafted and old school grading of a "C" being average (ie , they did what they should have done), how did the NFC East Teams' drafts grade out?
Grading Scale
A+= 98,A = 95,A- = 92,B+ = 88,B = 85,B- = 82,C+= 78,C = 75,C- = 72,D+ = 68,D = 65,D - = 62,F = 60
Weighting by Round (Considered Starting % and Pro Bowl %- see other thread)
1st = 40%
2nd = 20%
3rd = 15%
4th = 10%
5th = 7%
6th = 5%
7th = 3%
Had to adjust a little when teams didn’t have 7 picks, one in each round.
NFC East Draft Grades
1.Eagles = 88.16 = B+
2.Giants = 74.74 = C
3.Cowboys = 67.54 = D+
4.Commies = 67.20 = D+
Once again, we’re the class of the NFC East. Really good draft by Howie and the team.
Below, are the detailed grade calculation of each NFC East Team
(round, overall pick, name, Pos, ranking, letter grade, # grade, weight, contribution)
EAGLES
1- 9-Carter-DT- 4-A—95-40%-38.00
1-31-Smith-OLB-26-B+-88-20%-17.20
3-65-Steen-OT-89-D-65-11%-7.15
3-66-Brown-S-79-C- -72-11%-7.92
4-105-Ringo-CB-39-A+ - 98-10%-9.80
6-188-McKee-QB-148-A-95-5% -4.75
7-249-Ojomo-DE-127-A+ - 98-3%-2.94
Total Eagles Score 88.16 = B+
COWBOYS
1-26-Smith-DT-33-C-75-40%-28.80
2-58-Schoonmaker-TE-105-F-60-20%- 12.00
3-90-Overshown-LB-118-D-65-15% -9.75
4-129-Fehoko-DE-169-D-65-10%-6.50
5-160-Richards-OT-197-D-65-7% - 4.55
6-178 – Scott – CB-434-F-60-3% - 1.80
6-212-Vaugn-RB-164-A+-98-3%-2.94
7-244-Brooks-WR-374-F-60-2%-1.20
Total Cowboys Score 67.54 = D+
GIANTS
1-24-Banks-CB-36-D-65-40%-26.00
2-57-Schmitz-C-54-C-75-22%-16.50
3-73-Hyatt-WR-61-B-85-18%-15.30
5-172-Gray-RB-123-A+-98-10%-9.80
6-209-Hawkins-CB-329-F-60-4%-2.40
7-243-Riley-DT-428-F-60-3%-1.80
7-254-Owens-S-200-A+-98-3%-2.94
Total Giants Score 74.74 = C
COMMIES
1-16-Forbes-CB-28-D-65-40%-26.00
2-47-Martin-CB-69-D-65-20%-13.00
3-97-Stromberg-C-133-D-65-15%-9.75
4-118-Daniels-OG-121-C-75-10%-7.50
5-137-Henry-DE-134-C-75-7%-5.25
6-193-Rodriguez-RB-206-C-75-5%-3.75
7-233-Jones-DE-301-D-65-3%-1.95
Total Commies Score 67.20 = D+
Grading Scale
A+= 98,A = 95,A- = 92,B+ = 88,B = 85,B- = 82,C+= 78,C = 75,C- = 72,D+ = 68,D = 65,D - = 62,F = 60
Weighting by Round (Considered Starting % and Pro Bowl %- see other thread)
1st = 40%
2nd = 20%
3rd = 15%
4th = 10%
5th = 7%
6th = 5%
7th = 3%
Had to adjust a little when teams didn’t have 7 picks, one in each round.
NFC East Draft Grades
1.Eagles = 88.16 = B+
2.Giants = 74.74 = C
3.Cowboys = 67.54 = D+
4.Commies = 67.20 = D+
Once again, we’re the class of the NFC East. Really good draft by Howie and the team.
Below, are the detailed grade calculation of each NFC East Team
(round, overall pick, name, Pos, ranking, letter grade, # grade, weight, contribution)
EAGLES
1- 9-Carter-DT- 4-A—95-40%-38.00
1-31-Smith-OLB-26-B+-88-20%-17.20
3-65-Steen-OT-89-D-65-11%-7.15
3-66-Brown-S-79-C- -72-11%-7.92
4-105-Ringo-CB-39-A+ - 98-10%-9.80
6-188-McKee-QB-148-A-95-5% -4.75
7-249-Ojomo-DE-127-A+ - 98-3%-2.94
Total Eagles Score 88.16 = B+
COWBOYS
1-26-Smith-DT-33-C-75-40%-28.80
2-58-Schoonmaker-TE-105-F-60-20%- 12.00
3-90-Overshown-LB-118-D-65-15% -9.75
4-129-Fehoko-DE-169-D-65-10%-6.50
5-160-Richards-OT-197-D-65-7% - 4.55
6-178 – Scott – CB-434-F-60-3% - 1.80
6-212-Vaugn-RB-164-A+-98-3%-2.94
7-244-Brooks-WR-374-F-60-2%-1.20
Total Cowboys Score 67.54 = D+
GIANTS
1-24-Banks-CB-36-D-65-40%-26.00
2-57-Schmitz-C-54-C-75-22%-16.50
3-73-Hyatt-WR-61-B-85-18%-15.30
5-172-Gray-RB-123-A+-98-10%-9.80
6-209-Hawkins-CB-329-F-60-4%-2.40
7-243-Riley-DT-428-F-60-3%-1.80
7-254-Owens-S-200-A+-98-3%-2.94
Total Giants Score 74.74 = C
COMMIES
1-16-Forbes-CB-28-D-65-40%-26.00
2-47-Martin-CB-69-D-65-20%-13.00
3-97-Stromberg-C-133-D-65-15%-9.75
4-118-Daniels-OG-121-C-75-10%-7.50
5-137-Henry-DE-134-C-75-7%-5.25
6-193-Rodriguez-RB-206-C-75-5%-3.75
7-233-Jones-DE-301-D-65-3%-1.95
Total Commies Score 67.20 = D+