Post by nephillymike on Aug 3, 2019 20:03:04 GMT -5
For Fathers Day, I got a subscription to the Athletic which a subscription only service that has high quality articles.
one article from over a week ago was a ranking of NFL QB based on the opinions of 55 coaches and executives.
They rank them in tiers, one thru five.
Tier 1 - they carry a team each week. The team wins because of him. They are placed in the tier that the majority of the execs and coaches place them in. An average of 1.0 means that every person rated them tier one and so on.
1. Rodgers 1.04
2. Brady 1.05
3. Brees 1.07
4. Mahomes 1.13
5. Luck 1.25
6. Rivers 1.40
7. Roethlisberger 1.42
8. Wilson 1.47
=================
Tier 2 - Can carry a team sometimes, but not as consistently as tier 1 and have a hole or two in their game
9. Ryan 1.82
10. Wentz 2.20
11. Stafford 2.22
12. Watson 2.27
12. Goff 2.27
14. Mayfield 2.53
==================
Tier 3 - Legitimate starter but needs a heavier running game or defense to win
15. Newton 2.57
16. Cousins 2.71
17. Prescott 2.73
18. Foles 2.76
19. Garapolo 2.89
20. Carr 2.93
21. Flacco 2.98
22. Dalton 3.04
22. Winston 3.04
24. Manning 3.05
25. Trubitsky 3.07
26. Mariota 3.13
27. Darnold 3.15
==============
Tier 4 - unproven player with upside, or a veteran suited as a backup
28. L. Jackson 3.67
29. Allen 3.69
30. Fitzpatrick 3.78
31. Keenum 3.84
32. Rosen 3.89
===============
No starters were Tier 5
I thought the list was pretty good overall.
I may move Stafford in front of Wentz, maybe move Foles up a few, Fitz up a few, Keenum up a few.
How many tier 3 guys make the HOF? This is why Sheli don't belong.
Surprised at Tribitsky being so low and how the rose has faded for Mariota.
Anyone?
one article from over a week ago was a ranking of NFL QB based on the opinions of 55 coaches and executives.
They rank them in tiers, one thru five.
Tier 1 - they carry a team each week. The team wins because of him. They are placed in the tier that the majority of the execs and coaches place them in. An average of 1.0 means that every person rated them tier one and so on.
1. Rodgers 1.04
2. Brady 1.05
3. Brees 1.07
4. Mahomes 1.13
5. Luck 1.25
6. Rivers 1.40
7. Roethlisberger 1.42
8. Wilson 1.47
=================
Tier 2 - Can carry a team sometimes, but not as consistently as tier 1 and have a hole or two in their game
9. Ryan 1.82
10. Wentz 2.20
11. Stafford 2.22
12. Watson 2.27
12. Goff 2.27
14. Mayfield 2.53
==================
Tier 3 - Legitimate starter but needs a heavier running game or defense to win
15. Newton 2.57
16. Cousins 2.71
17. Prescott 2.73
18. Foles 2.76
19. Garapolo 2.89
20. Carr 2.93
21. Flacco 2.98
22. Dalton 3.04
22. Winston 3.04
24. Manning 3.05
25. Trubitsky 3.07
26. Mariota 3.13
27. Darnold 3.15
==============
Tier 4 - unproven player with upside, or a veteran suited as a backup
28. L. Jackson 3.67
29. Allen 3.69
30. Fitzpatrick 3.78
31. Keenum 3.84
32. Rosen 3.89
===============
No starters were Tier 5
I thought the list was pretty good overall.
I may move Stafford in front of Wentz, maybe move Foles up a few, Fitz up a few, Keenum up a few.
How many tier 3 guys make the HOF? This is why Sheli don't belong.
Surprised at Tribitsky being so low and how the rose has faded for Mariota.
Anyone?
